Oh god I have a lot to catch up to O_O
Main theme song, orchestral theme, appreciate the feedback
Nice work! You handled very well creating a somewhat melancholic song but with a touch of hope, especially in the intro.
If I were to add my grain of salt though, I'd say it takes a very long time to introduce a new motif (at around 2:40), the intro is nice but gets a bit repetitive.
I would do what you did when you reintroduced the motif after the second part, but minus the percussion.
You don't have to make it shorter, I would have added some more instruments (that would add to the feeling of hope imo), like brass maybe.
Your percussion sounds very very unnatural in the second part (that might be artistic choice so if it's what you were going for then don't change it).
Overall a really nice track, I thouroughly enjoyed that
:)
Here's my latest creation if it can be called that. I metalled up some traditional irish music because I'm just getting back into composing and orchestration.
A few things that would make the song perfect (because it's pretty close to being that):
Articulate the strings so they sound more natural. Idk how limited you are by the samples you are using but the least you can do is 1) volume articulation and 2) reverb (not too much since the rest of your songs is rather dry)
Use Equalisation to make your track less "muddy". Right now the instruments are clashing together for space and don't sit well together.
You should make sure your bass and kickdrum don't use up too much high-end, and that your violin and snaredrums don't take up too much low-end.
Otherwise I really like this song!
Well, here's mine. But sounds like Russian to me.
Really nice song! I'd like to hear the bass more though, it should probably play one octave lower imo. It's repetitive but it would work very well for a battle track.
The 8-bit version also works very well. For the riff I think you have a very cool idea, if you actually develop it be sure to post it here, I'd love to hear the full result.
I'd love to get some feedback on those. They're quite old by now and I just polished the first one here, but I still personally like them a lot.
Same advice as padr81, your first song sounds very muddy to me. Make sure you EQ your tracks and make your instruments sit well in the mix.
It's not as bad in the second track. I think the main issue in this one is the piano which plays very fast notes without much articulation. If you make eah note play at a slightly different volume it's sound much more natural.
I think both tracks work very well for an rpg game, so if you fix those things it'll sound great!
I'm working on a small modern ost that I'll post in this forum for free, this is an example of the main style of the tracks
Dude nothing to critique, this is amazing quality
:thumbsup-right:
...
okay actually if I were to be super annoying: pls add room reverb to your drums.
But still, even if you leave it this way it sounds amazing!
Thank you so much everyone (especially
@Tirian) for the feedback, it is really appreciated. Since you enjoyed my piano improvisation, let me share with you more of them. Again, YouTube only, but I will upload them soon on SoundCloud (I recently have a very narrow schedule, thus the delay in uploading.)
Back to the topic, these are the impros I was talking about. This time, not blindfolded, but I hope you will still enjoy them
:p
<3 <3 <3
I really like your first song. Like Kaimen said, I think you could make the harp a bit less present and bring the vocals forward a bit. What did you use for those btw?
Your second song also has some volume issues, make sure all your tracks are loud enough and not too loud. Otherwise it's very good, I love the irish influence in your songs
:)
Made that as a commission long ago. Actually my first attempt at a more jazzy battle theme. Personally, I think maybe I could've done better but I'm pretty satisfied with it regardless. Let me know what you guys think.
Here the song is also a bit muddy, I think it's because the piano is playing the same notes as the bass (I mean as low as the bass). Tell me if I'm wrong, but if that's the case it might cause the lows to clash together.
Alright.. A short piece I just made. I've never made battle music before :kaoswt2:
Very nice, not much to critique imo. I'm curious: what did you use for the choir?
---
Since I last posted here I released an orchestral remix of Genesis by Protostar (last month ^^')
Here it is:
Soundcloud link if you prefer: